The film opens with the aforementioned infamous crawl about taxation and trade routes:
Turmoil
has engulfed the Galactic Republic. The taxation of trade routes to
outlying star systems is in dispute.
Hoping
to resolve the matter with a blockade of deadly battleships, the
greedy Trade Federation has stopped all shipping to the small planet
of Naboo.
While
the congress of the Republic endlessly debates this alarming chain of
events, the Supreme Chancellor has secretly dispatched two Jedi
Knights, the guardians of peace and justice in the galaxy, to settle
the conflict...
And just like that, the world record for screwing up your movie is set, besides casting Taylor Kitsch to star in your movie. The problem here is all of this is over the taxation of trade routes. In a Star Wars movie. Change this to the assassination of a key political figure or territory disputes, anything over freaking taxes. I suppose taxes could work if we saw ANY kind of effect they were having on anyone, but that's the absolute theme of this movie: NOTHING is explained whatsoever.
How is stopping
shipping to the small planet of Naboo going to resolve a tax dispute?
The Trade Federation (whose role isn't explained) wants the taxes on
trade routes to outlying star systems increased or decreased (we're
never told), so they block all shipping to Naboo by setting up a huge
fleet of battleships. This is meant to
make the Republic Congress give in and increase or decrease the
taxes, but they instead debate back and forth. What is the
pro-blockade side of this saying? “Yeah, it's totally cool to
deprive Naboo of all their goods, even though they're part of the
Republic so should be automatically under our protection!”.
I mean, everyone
in Congress knows about the blockade right? This is an outright and
deliberate assault on a Republic planet AND the ships that arrive to
deliver them goods (because the blockade is DEADLY), what is there to
debate about? There hasn't been a single actor on the screen yet and
already I'm bogged down trying to figure out plot points. Not to mention,
the Trade Federation isn't like its own world, right? They're just a
large company that the Republic hired to deliver goods for them, and
now they want more money because they're “greedy”. Why does the
Republic have to bother with any of this? Can't they just fire the
Federation instead of having to debate in the senate what they want
to do? This is like if Pepsi wanted more money from Walmart and set
up a barricade in front of a store. Whew! Hard to
believe it's been fifteen years already! Well, thanks for reading
and- oh wait, there's still a movie to deal with isn't there?
A Republic ship
carrying the two Jedi ambassadors, Qui-Gon Jinn and Obi-Wan Kenobi,
arrives at the blockade, the pilot hailing the Trade Federation in
one of the most distractingly hoarse voices I've ever heard. Do they
not have lozenges in the future? Or a long, long time ago or
whenever the hell Star Wars is supposed to take place? Nute Gunray, the
Viceroy of the Trade Federation, answers the call and agrees to this.
On a side note here, I believe when Lucas was writing this movie he
just threw out whatever big sounding political word he could think of
to describe someone.
Federation: a
group of various bodies or parties that have united to achieve a
common goal.
Viceroy: a governor who represents a
sovereign in a province, colony, or country.I know, I know: they're all aliens so they probably have different definitions for the same words we do but that's WEAK. You really couldn't use like “Chief Executive Officer” of the Federation or something like that? It doesn't help this movie when every few lines I have to stop and puzzle over something. Speaking of which, Gunray adds “as you know, our blockade is perfectly legal”. Ohhhhhh this is going to be the longest review ever. Why is the blockade legal? This private company is cutting off supplies to a member of the Republic, this is the DEFINITION of illegal. I know I'm beating this point to death, but none of this makes any sense. Why is the Republic allowing this? What is there to debate?! What is the pro-blockade side of this?!?
The Jedi are
escorted by protocol droid TC-14 to a meeting room, where Obi-Wan
immediately says the series catchphrase “I have a bad feeling about
this”. So do I Obi-Wan, so do I. Good idea to get the cliches out
of the way immediately so we can focused on the nuanced storyline
ahead of us. The Jedi ramble on about nothing, Qui-Gon assuring
Obi-Wan the negotiations will be short. TC-14 tells Gunray
the ambassadors are Jedi, Gunray's sidekick Daultay Dofine saying
they are here to force a settlement. Why wouldn't they? Did you
expect them to be happy you're screwing with one of the Republic's
members? People are pretty freaking stupid in this movie. Gunray goes
to call “Lord Sidious” to get advice on what to do.
The Jedi, like
everyone watching this, are getting bored sitting around in the
waiting room. Qui-Gon says he senses an unusual amount of fear for
something as trivial as this trade dispute. If it's so trivial, why
has it brought the entire Congress to a standstill? TC-14 brings them
drinks, which they readily gulp down. Wasn't I just saying something
about everyone being stupid in this movie? Good thing those weren't
poisoned! Gunray calls Lord
Sidious, who appears as a hologram. Dofine bitches and whines, so the
hologram kicks him out of the Bad Guys Club. Sidious tells Gunray to
begin landing his troops on Naboo, the viceroy asking if that's
legal. Sidious say's he'll make it legal, adding Gunray should kill
the Jedi as well. We're going to talk about Sidious down the road, so
I'm going to save all my ranting about our villains until then.
In the landing
bay, laser cannons pop up and blast the Republic ship into oblivion.
The loud explosion alerts the Jedi, who immediately bolt up and draw
their light sabers. Geez, jumpy much? What if that was just an
accident with some barrels or something? Do they just draw their
sabers every time they hear a loud noise? I
feel sorry for any pets these guys have.
Rather, had. Poison gas begins
pumping into the room, both Jedi holding their breath. Battle droids
amass outside the waiting room, a hologram of Gunray telling them the
Jedi must be dead by now and to destroy what's left. They don't have
cameras in that room to make sure of that first? Or why not just let
the gas stay in there for hours just to be sure? Oh wait, these guys
are stupid so never mind.
They open the
doors, the view inside obscured by the toxic gas. We see two light
sabers emerge from the gas as the droids open fire. The Jedi
completely obliterate them, because the battle droids are TOTALLY
WORTHLESS IN THIS MOVIE. To be fair, in the original trilogy the
Stormtroopers ended up totally worthless themselves, but at least it
took them three movies until they got their asses handed to them by
teddy bears. The Jedi make
their way to the bridge where Gunray is, but he dispatches rolling
Destroyer Droids to stop them. The Destroyer Droids open fire, so the
Jedi run away at LIGHTNING SPEED. Wait,
does this mean the Flash is a Jedi too then? Is the Speed Force
actually THE Force?!
The Jedi escape
into a different ship bay where they find a huge invasion force
awaiting deployment. Qui-Gon says they need to warn the Naboo and
contact Chancellor Valorum, which is a good idea. He recommends they
split up and stow away on separate ships and meet down on the planet,
which is a TERRIBLE idea. Warn the freaking
Naboo from the ship! By the time you're on the planet it's going to
be too late to warn them, isn't it? And why the hell would you split
up? You have no idea where these ships are headed. What if you wind
up on completely different parts of the planet? I honestly don't
remember the characters being THIS stupid. Obi-Wan does take a moment
to crack a joke that Qui-Gon was right, the negotiations were short.
Obi-Wan says this
with a really strange look on his face that I believe is called a
“smile”. This is a very odd characteristic for any of the main
characters in this movie to have. Gunray gets a video call from Queen
Monotone Amidala of the Naboo, who tells him she has bad news. Is
she pregnant? No that's not it, she tells him his “trade boycott”
of her planet is now over. Wait, it's a boycott now?
Boycott: to cease or refuse to deal with something such as an organization, a company, or a process, as a protest against it or as an effort to force it to become more acceptable
So the TRADE Federation is boycotting TRADE? Shouldn't this be the other way around with the Republic boycotting the Trade Federation over their blockade? Have I been able to go a scene without asking questions about something in it that made no sense? Monotone has word Valorum's ambassadors are with him now and that Gunray's been commanded to reach a settlement. Oh, Valorum COMMANDS it huh? Why in the hell didn't he do that in the first place? You know, what exactly are his powers? He can't be that powerful if he had to send the Jedi in secret to handle this whole debacle. Gunray says he knows nothing of any ambassadors. Monotone warns him he's gone too far. The viceroy tells her he'd never do anything without the approval of the Senate. So the Senate- wait, the Senate? I thought it was the Congress? You know, a Senate and Congress aren't the same thing Lucas.
So the Senate
approved this blockade since the Federation would “never do
anything without their approval”. Why would they approve that?!
That's how it's legal? What in God's name is going on in this
movie?!? After Monotone
hangs up, Gunray talks with his new sidekick Rune Haako, who
has one of the most bitchingly awesome hats in history. He's the one
who should be running this show.
Rune asks Gunray
if he thinks Monotone suspects an invasion. Gunray doesn't know, but
orders all communications to or from the planet jammed just in case.
This scene shocked the hell out of me because someone actually did
something smart. On Naboo, Monotone
calls the planet's Republic representative, Senator Palpatine, via hologram to tell him what Gunray
said, but their call gets broken up by the jamming. She has a meeting
with some heads of state or something, Naboo Governor Sio Bibble
saying the jamming can only mean one thing: invasion.
Chief of Security
Quarsh Panaka says the Federation can't invade because the Senate
would revoke their trade franchise and they'd be finished. I... I honestly
can't take anymore of this. This is UNREAL. The Phantom Menace
drinking game is take a shot every time something involving the
Federation makes no sense. If
you want to play extreme and kill your liver dead, take a shot every
time something IN GENERAL makes no sense.
He goes on to say Naboo's security volunteers are no match against a “battle hardened Trade Federation army”. It's established Naboo is like a peaceful paradise, so I can forgive them not having an army but why does the Federation? Security, sure. We've seen shipping interstellar cargo can be a dangerous thing thanks to space pirates, but a “battle hardened one” capable of throwing up blockades over an entire planet? I hate to keep harping on this, but it's mind blowing how changing the Trade Federation to a rebelling planet would have fixed SO much stuff in this movie. Two simple words. Monotone says her famous “I will not condone a course of action that will lead us to war”. What, defending your people? Yeah, that's not important at all.
We see a ton of
Federation ships land on Naboo in the middle of nowhere. This is
something else I remember from fifteen years ago, why did they land
so far away? Surely the Naboo would have noticed this and had plenty
of time to scrape up their legendary security volunteers, or at the
least go into hiding. On that topic, why did the Federation needs all
of this if the Naboo doesn't even have an army? Why not just land a
single ship and take over Theed Palace?
Gunray calls droid captain OOM-9, telling him they can't find the Jedi on the ship and they must have stowed away to the planet. We cut to Qui-Gon, who is running ahead of a fleet of giant hovering tanks cutting a path of destruction through the forest. Uh, so no one just sees him there? I mean, he's like RIGHT in front of the tanks. As Qui-Gon runs, we see fan favourite character JAR JAR BINKS make his triumphant Star Wars debut. He's just standing there, waving his arms and going “oh no!” instead of trying to, you know, get out of the way of the tanks. Somewhere, Dr. Shaw and Captain Vickers from Prometheus are laughing their arses off derisively.
Since Jar Jar is
to stupid to move, Qui-Gon tackles him to the ground to save him from
getting steamrolled by the tank. You realize we're only ELEVEN
minutes into this thing? I mean, the movie has been relentlessly curb
stomping our brains since it started and now it's throwing Jar Jar at
us? This has to be a violation of the Geneva Convention. Jar Jar tags along
with Qui-Gon. The way he talks... oh boy. I didn't forget how bad it
was, but hearing again it is SO BAD. I suppose this is the part where
I should talk about the accusations of racism in this movie, how some
of the characters talk like racial stereotypes.
I don't know, this never bothered me very much because honestly I don't believe it was intentional. You think a zillionaire like Lucas, who's been sequestered in his crystal palace since the 1980s, has ANY idea how the world has evolved since then? Qui-Gon tells Jar Jar to GTFO, but the gungan gives us this gem: “Mesa culled Jar Jar Binks. Mesa your humble servant!”
I don't know, this never bothered me very much because honestly I don't believe it was intentional. You think a zillionaire like Lucas, who's been sequestered in his crystal palace since the 1980s, has ANY idea how the world has evolved since then? Qui-Gon tells Jar Jar to GTFO, but the gungan gives us this gem: “Mesa culled Jar Jar Binks. Mesa your humble servant!”
Yikes. Okay, maybe a little racist. Suddenly Obi-Wan runs into the picture, being chased by battle droids on those cool hover Segways of theirs. Qui-Gon quickly takes them out by using his light saber to return their blaster fire back at them. It's worth noting there's a scene in the shooting script where Obi-Wan reveals his saber got shorted out in the water and now doesn't work. Qui-Gon tells him it'll recharge and be functional in time, telling him next time to make sure he turns off its power so that doesn't happen again. I thought that was a neat little scene that added some insight to light
sabers, but yeah let's cut that for some more WACKY HIJINX with Jar Jar.
Apparently the
battle droids didn't bother calling for backup or telling anyone they
found the Jedi, because no more appear. Jar Jar tells them the safest
place would be Gunga City, which makes Qui-Gon's ears perk up. I
guess this is because he thinks this will be a good place to contact
the Naboo and Valorum, but I'm wondering why they don't use their
super speed to run to Theed.
Jar Jar then backpedals a bit and says he can't take them there because he's been banished, but Qui-Gon talks him into it. They head to the shoreline of a sea, Jar Jar telling them the city is underwater. I hated this part a LOT the first go around, and it turns out I still do.
So... how are the Jedi going to get to this city that is deep underwater? Hold their breath for a very long time thanks to their mastery of the Force, like we've seen they can do? Noooo, they pull out these little re-breather devices that they just HAPPEN to have in their robes. I despise this, as with the exception of a light saber the very idea of a Jedi is the rejection of dependence upon technology. A Jedi uses the the Force, their willpower, and their intellect to overcome obstacles rather than machines. That was one of the core concepts of the original trilogy, and by far one of my favourite things I got out of those movies.
And just to add
some icing on this cake of wrongness, the Jedi enter the water
wearing their heavy ass robes. They have to make swimming so awkward,
but I guess the Jedi use the Force to make them lighter? Sigh. They enter the
city, immediately taken into custody by Captain Roos Tarpals. He
brings them to “da bosses”, and I just noticed every single
authority figure in this movie sits in a semi circle or a full
circle. The leader of the gungans is Boss
Rugor Nass, who looks nothing like the other gungans. He's either
really really fat or a different species altogether. Nope, he must be
a gungan because I can't understand anything he's saying either.
“Dis army of
Mackineeks up dare is new weesong”. Yeah okay there, sure.
Qui-Gon tells him they need to warn the Naboo. You know Qui-Gon, you keep prattling on about warning them, what exactly are you going to do? As an ambassador, shouldn't you have researched the planet and discovered the Naboo have no army? Hell, shouldn't you have known about the gungans and Gunga City? But Jar Jar did say it's hidden, so maybe that's a secret to the Republic so I'll let that one go. Really at this point calling Valorum should be tops of your list so he could send some REAL help?
Nass doesn't care about any of this because they hate the Naboo. This is something I would have loved to see elaborated on more, or at all for that reason. Why do the two races hate each other? Just give me an OUNCE of depth movie, that's all I ask! Obi-Wan tells him once the droids take control of the surface, they'll take control of the gungans. But if their city is a secret, how would the Federation know about it? Nass backs me up on this one, saying the droids don't know about them. Obi-Wan busts out one of the weirdest replies I've ever heard. “You and the Naboo form a symbiont circle. What happens to one of you will affect the other. You must understand this.”. Qui-Gon gets fed up with all this bullshit so does what he should have done in the first place: the Jedi mind trick.
He makes Nass give him a ship so they can leave, the gungan telling him the quickest way to the Naboo is through “the planet core”. I don't think Lucas knows what a core is either. You know what bugs me about this scene? When Qui-Gon uses the mind trick on Nass, we get a reaction shot of Jar Jar looking super confused as to why Nass is suddenly helping them. Now of course WE all know what Qui-Gon's doing, but imagine a first time viewer watching this. I'm sure there's some out there, there certainly will be next generation and they'll watch the movies in numerical order. They'll have no idea what's going on here, especially since the framing here is terrible and you can barely see Qui-Gon waving his hand.
The Jedi go to
leave, Jar Jar asking them for help. Obi-Wan's all “AWW HELL NO!”,
but Qui-Gon says “we'll need a navigator to get us through the
planet's core”. REMEMBER THIS SENTENCE. Qui-Gon tells Nass
that he saved Jar Jar's life and now he owes him what the gungans
call a “life debt”. Except the scene where Jar Jar uses those
exact words was cut from the movie, so this part doesn't make a lot
of sense. Oops! Nass sends Jar Jar along with the Jedi. You know
what? We are only SIXTEEN minutes into this thing. I've seen glaciers
that could run circles around the pace of this movie.
Upon learning he's free, Jar Jar spouts this sentence of sheer WTFery: “Count me outta dis one. Better dead here than dead in da core. Yee gods! What mesa sayin'?!” I HAVE NO FREAKING IDEA! They leave in the ship, which is called a bongo. Obi-Wan drives, somehow knowing how to expertly pilot the totally alien craft that he's never operated in his entire life. He asks Jar Jar why he was banished, and we get an answer I was never able to understand thanks to Jar Jar's gibberish. Subtitles, take it away!
“It's a longo tale-o. Buta small part of it would be mesa... clumsy.”
“Yousa might'n be sayin' dat. Mesa caused mabbe one, two-y lettle bitty axadentes, huh? Yud-say boom da gassar, den crashin' der boss's heyblibber, den banished.”
Ohhh, well that
makes COMPLETE sense now! I guess we can just close the book on that
fifteen year old mystery. A giant fish attacks the ship, using
its tongue as a tractor beam to draw the craft into its mouth. But
then an even bigger fish shows up and eats it, allowing the bongo to
escape. Qui-Gon quips “there's always a bigger fish”, which I
have to admit is about a perfect line. Back on the
Federation ship, Gunray tells Sidious the invasion is going as
planned. Sidious tells them he has the Senate bogged down in
procedures and they'll have no choice but to accept the Federation's
control of the system. The bongo
continues its trek through the “planet core”. Jar Jar asks where
they're going, and Qui-Gon replying “Don't worry. The Force will
guide us”.
I...
But...
You know what movie? No no no, seriously, you know what?! FUCK YOU! FUCK YOU SO MUCH! At 16:23 Qui-Gon says they'll need a navigator to help them through the core. At 19:24, THREE MINUTES LATER, they contradict this because all they need is the Force. Why did you bring Jar Jar along then?! What was Lucas drinking when he wrote this, and how much? Where are the bodies of the editors for this script buried? Jar says “Ohh, maxi big, da Force. Well, dat smells stinkowiff.”. Sure, I'll accept a completely isolationist society like the gungans would know about the Force but what the hell did the rest of that mean? Stinkowiff?! Was that a slam against the Force? Was he being sarcastic? How come Jabba The Hutt spoke better English than Jar Jar?
The bongo suddenly
loses power as a result of the fish attack. Obi-Wan, who can fix any
alien technology that he's never encountered before, repairs the
entire ship by simply hotwiring it. I bet the Force told him how to
do it! Moving one single little wire is somehow able to undo all the
massive physical damage we see on the outside of the bongo from where
the fish bit into it. As the bongo's
lights come back on, we see another giant fish. Jar Jar starts
freaking out so Qui-Gon gives him the Vulcan nerve pinch to shut him
up, and instantly this movie is awesome! They race away from the
fish, but then ANOTHER even gianter fish shows up to save them. I
guess this is a running gag now so it's funny? No? Oh.
We cut to the
outskirts of Theed, where the Federation's invasion force is
traveling through an endless sprawl of beautiful green grass and
hills. This is where they should have landed instead of that forest
with all of its trees and hard to see areas. We get a beautiful shot
of Monotone sadly watching them arrive, which is easily my favourite
shot in the entire movie. A bit later Gunray
and Rune arrive in Theed, learning the queen has been captured. I
would have much rather seen her capture than the bongo nonsense, but
this really isn't that kind of movie. Speaking of the bongo, it
surfaces in a body of water right by the palace. Convenient!
Gunray and his
army escort Monotone and her people through the city. Bibble asks how
they'll justify this invasion to the Senate, Gunray telling him the
queen will sign a treaty that will “legitimize” their occupation
which the Senate will ratify. He has his droids take her to a
makeshift prison camp. I'm holding off on THAT for a moment to point
out Monotone has changed into a completely new and extravagant black
costume, which I believe is the “Captive Queen” outfit. We've
come a LONG way from “Slave Leia”.
In the original trilogy the characters change clothes somewhat often, which was very refreshing for the sci-fi genre. I'm NOT going to be cynical here and say it was so they could make more toys to sell, but the costume changes were always very practical. Leia changed clothes the most, and I believe they made Monotone pay homage to that because she changes clothes a LOT in this movie. However here it's almost never practical, because her outfits look incredibly complex and time consuming to change into.
This part is incredibly stupid, because it makes me think this happened: “Oh there's thousands of droids coming! Instead of trying to hide, escape, or marshal a resistance, I'm going to spend an hour changing clothes and doing my makeup! I don't want to end up on TMZ with the caption 'Kidnapped Queen a Hot Mess'!”. Or even better, the droids politely wait outside her bathroom while she “goes to change”. We hear a window open, exaggerated running, a car door opening and slamming shut, a motor turning over, and tires loudly squeal off, the droids making small talk and whistling.
Monotone tells Gunray she won't sign the treaty. He says she will when she see how her people will suffer. Alright, I've stalled long enough. Incredibly enough, I think THIS was the most moronic part of the entire thing. WHY do they need her to sign the treaty? WHY couldn't they just forge her signature? After every illegal thing they've done, FORGERY is where they draw the line? Why would the Senate need to ratify a treaty for a trading company to settle on a planet? I mean, they're not part of the Republic, they just had a contract with them or whatever. I imagine them as the equivalent of a tobacco company that has great power in the Senate because they buy everyone off, but if such a company suddenly took over part of America would our Senate need to ratify a treaty between Marlboro and Oregon? Again, this is something you can all chalk up to “they're aliens, their cultures are going to be different than ours” but if that's the case WHY NOT JUST MAKE THE FEDERATION A REBEL PLANET?!?
Psst... only 22 minutes into the film. I know this because this is where I stopped for a break because my head was beginning to get the brain pains. The Jedi leap off a ledge and take out all the battle droids like they were made of paper. Well, the whole “warning the Naboo” thing you were so obsessed with didn't work out so well, did it Qui-Gon? He tells Monotone they're the ambassadors and the negotiations never took place. He says it's urgent they contact the Republic, but Panaka tells him about the jamming. Qui-Gon decides they need to take a ship and leave through the deadly blockade. That... doesn't seem wise.
They head to the
main hangar bay, which is full of battle droids who are guarding a
bunch of captive pilots. Qui-Gon tells Panaka they won't be a problem
like any of us were worried for a nanosecond. Why even have the
battle droids in this movie at all? Why not use Destroyer Droids, the
only thing that the Jedi apparently can't defeat? Sure you always
knew the Stormtroopers weren't going to win, but at least they were
an effective enemy that always overwhelmed our heroes and forced them
to use their heads to win. Qui-Gon wants
Monotone to come to the Republic capital of Coruscant with them so she can relay the situation. She
says her place is with her people but the Jedi tells her the
Federation will kill her. Panaka says no way, they need her to sign
the treaty to make their invasion legal.
Bibble says she
should go because Palpatine will need her assistance to get the
Senate to help them out. Bibble reminds me to point out something
about this movie I've failed to mention: the acting BLOWS. Every
character is either “bored student reading out loud to the class in
a monotone voice” or “first time actor doing a table read”
level. I'll really expound on this later, but Lucas had really
devolved into a GODAWFUL director at this point. He has some of the
finest actors of this generation in this movie and does not care to
even attempt to get a performance of any kind out of them. I bet
there were a LOT of single takes in this movie.
Monotone says either choice presents grave danger and looks at one of her handmaidens who says “we are brave, your highness”. Okay, usually when I do these reviews I've never seen the movie and have no idea what's going to happen next but since I've seen this one I'm going to spoil something here. The queen is not the queen, but actually a decoy named Sabe. Sabe is played by Keira Knightley, who looked so identical to Natalie Portman that when in makeup that their parents couldn't tell them apart on the filming set. Hell, I can barely tell them apart WITHOUT makeup!
The handmaiden is Padme Amidala, who is actually the queen. Though I've always wondered why she used her real name when in disguise, you think someone would have noticed that. Kind of defeats the purpose of using a decoy! The comment Padme made was her way of telling Sabe what to do, which is one of the few times this movie is being clever. Fun fact: one of the queen's other handmaidens is also quite famous, Sache is played by writer/director/kick ass gymnast Sofia Coppola. Congrats Sofia, the Godfather 3 is no longer the worst movie you've ever been in! "The queen" agrees to go with the Jedi. They enter the hangar bay, the droids stopping them instead of opening fire for some reason. Sure they need the queen alive, but why not just shoot everyone else? But I guess so it's we can have this weird scene:
Qui-Gon: I'm the
ambassador to the Supreme Chancellor. I'm taking these people to
Coruscant.
Droid: Where are you taking them?Qui-Gon: To Coruscant.
Droid: Coruscant. Uh, that doesn't compute. Uh, wait. You're under arrest.
Why does the robot say “uh”? Why would you program a robot to say “uh”? Let's compare this to the shooting script:
Droid : Where are you going?
Droid: You're under arrest!
That's just fine, why change that? I guess ANY chance Lucas had to throw in some kind of “comedy”, he was going to take it. Remember years ago when Lucas announced he and Seth Green were going to make a Star Wars comedy, which never materialized? Consider the Phantom Menace the pilot episode.
No comments:
Post a Comment